Flightradar24 Blog

JAL vs ANA: comparing the Japanese airlines

JAL vs ANA Japan Airlines All Nippon Airways 777 flights pandemic

JAL vs ANA: comparing the Japanese airlines

Share this article
Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on email

Like many countries in Asia, Japan has kept the coronavirus from spreading rampant within its borders. Good news for the Japanese, though one downside for the rest of us is that the country has been largely closed to outsiders. There has been talk of a potential, very careful reopening from April next year, but this remains talk for now. Aside from returning citizens and residents, the only people flying in and out have been a very small number of business travelers from approved countries.

Japan Airlines JAL A350 Tokyo
A Japan Airlines A350 taking off from Tokyo Haneda (HND)

With that in mind, it’s surprising to see just how much the two major Japanese airlines, All Nippon Airways (NH) and Japan Airlines (JL) have been flying this autumn. Considering Japan’s previously booming tourism sector was more or less shut down overnight, they’re managing to operate quite a few flights. Looking at Flightradar24’s tracking data, here are some of the trends we’ve noticed.

Japan Airlines is closing the gap

JAL (along with its domestic subsidiary J-Air) has noticeably closed the gap with ANA during the pandemic. Whereas in 2019 a typical autumn week at ANA would see roughly 5,500 flight departures in total, this year we’ve seen averages closer to 3,000 flights. During November of 2019 JAL and J-Air together had around 4,000 flights a week, whereas in recent weeks that total has been closer to 3,000. These numbers have fluctuated since September, but the total drop in flights has been much bigger at ANA.

ANA-JAL Weekly Flights 2019 vs 2020

Both have been flying more recently

The total flight numbers from September compared to now show a marked increase in flying, even as Japan has barely opened its borders. From under 4,000 total flights across both carriers in the first week of September, departures topped 6,000 every week in November. The number of added flights are quite even comparing JAL and ANA – it appears that both have added roughly the same number of flights during this time.

ANA-JAL Weekly Flights 2020 Combined

JAL’s share of domestic flights is up

Japan Airlines, along with its mostly domestic J-Air subsidiary, has been moving towards flying a greater share of domestic flights than ever, especially in November of this year. Even when removing J-Air flights from the count, JAL’s share of domestic flights as a percentage of total flights jumped to 76% in November. A year ago that number of 67%. In fact while in 2019 ANA led JAL and its subsidiaries by quite a wide margin for number of domestic flights, JAL carriers have beaten ANA for total domestic flights in each of the last three months. All of which tells us that some of the boost to total flying figures of late is likely down to domestic schedule additions, and that JAL has been a lot more active on this front than ANA this year.

ANA-JAL Domestic Weekly Flights 2019 and 2020

Some cities have more service than ever

While overall flying by both JAL and ANA is obviously down compared to 2019, there are some cities that are currently seeing more service than they did at this time last year. For example, ANA operated 14 flights out of San Francisco (SFO) in the last week of November. In the same week one year ago, it ran just 8 from there. Los Angeles (LAX) also saw one additional flight in the last week of November 2020, with 22 flights versus 21 in 2019. JAL shows some similar results. It flew 19 flights from LAX in the last week of November this year. The same week a year ago it flew 14 from there.

ANA All Nippon Airways 777 Osaka Itami
An All Nippon Airways 777 at Osaka Itami (ITM)

That’s not true everywhere, though. While both ANA and JAL served Seoul (ICN and GMP) roughly three times a day in autumn 2019, during the same period this year ANA has had no flights from Korea and JAL has averaged one per week.

ANA’s domestic drawdown and JAL’s milder version of same is well illustrated by flight numbers out of Sapporo (CTS), on the northern island of Hokkaido. While ANA’s flights there have been nearly cut in half compared to 2019 (with nearly 300 in a normal week last year and closer to 160 or so this year), JAL’s have seen a more modest drop of about a quarter.

Rumors of a merger between the two

There are suggestions that the Japanese government is considering merging JAL and ANA in order to help stem losses suffered amid the coronavirus downturn. Many observers have noted that this would be a shame, and I would tend to agree. ANA and JAL are some of the best airlines in the world, and each has their own way of doing things. It would mean a great loss of choice for passengers and the reduced competition in Japan would probably leave everyone worse off (except perhaps the shareholders). At this point, though, I don’t expect this to actually happen. With any luck things will start to rebound soon and both airlines can return to profitability.

Japan Airlines and ANA aircraft at Tokyo’s Haneda Airport
Japan Airlines and ANA aircraft at Tokyo’s Haneda Airport

Japan can’t open soon enough

It should be an interesting few months ahead as we see how vaccine distribution shapes up and countries like Japan (that have played things very carefully thus far) begin to allow visitors back in. Especially with the rescheduled Tokyo Olympics supposedly on their way for next summer. Will it be a mostly virtual event? Or will it herald a return to freedom of movement and a heady summer full of flights and travel? Either way, I’ll be on one of the first planes in to Tokyo when they do. I know many others have similar plans.

Featured image © Cameron Stone

Get the latest aviation news delivered to you

Join more than 500,000 others who receive weekly aviation industry and flight tracking news from Flightradar24 direct to their inbox.
Share this article
Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on email
Latest video
Get weekly updates on Flightradar24 and have the latest aviation news land in your inbox.
Search the blog
Trending articles
Follow us
Latest AvTalk Podcasts
Related news