Common Errors on Flightradar24
Flying cars, strange detours, impossible flight paths? When tracking hundreds of thousands of flights per day, various errors arise from time-to-time. We regularly get questions about why a particular flight track looks odd and the reason often falls in to a few categories.
Transponders can generate errors by transmitting random or incorrect position information, like the Air Canada flight below. This leads to impossible looking flight paths that often contain a jagged, switch-back look.
Outside the Runway
A more common type of transponder error leads to one of our most asked questions: “why did this plane land outside the runway?” While this can be alarming upon first glance, the aircraft has indeed landed on the runway. This error occurs when the transponder is relaying incorrect position data. On certain aircraft, such as older Airbus A300, Boeing 737, 757, or 767s (like the one in the photo below), position data is calibrated on the ground before takeoff and is subject to drift over the course of a flight. This error is compounded by the length of the flight, winds aloft, and circular holding patterns.
Wrong Transponder Code
We use the unique transponder code assigned to every aircraft to identify it and match it to our databases. If the transponder code is incorrect, it is likely that we will misidentify the flight. In the case below, the transponder code for a ground vehicle at Amsterdam’s Schipol Airport has been mistakenly entered into a flight departing Manaus, Brazil. Because of the wrong transponder code, we display a flying car.
Wrong transponder codes also play a role of making some flights look like they’re jumping all over the map. At any one time, about 10 aircraft are using the same incorrect code, such as “AAAAAA”, as their transponder code. We track all of those together as one flight, creating the illusion that the flight is jumping around the map. Other common invalid transponder codes included “000000” and “123456”.
Detours can happen with both MLAT and ADS-B if there is a problem with the signal. When tracking flights with ADS-B, if we receive a position report of 85 degrees of longitude instead of 84, an aircraft can jump one degree on the map. This can also happen when we’re tracking flights with MLAT when the signal is weak, such as on take off, landing, or low altitude flight. MLAT calculations are based on the speed of light, so a small timing error can create big errors on the map.
Data Source Errors
When tracking flights over water traveling to or from North America, we often rely on data from the Federal Aviation Administration. Errors in this data can result in flights being displayed as flying in the opposite direction in which they are actually traveling. For example, the Alaska Airlines flight below is flying from Seattle to Hawaii, but the FAA data error shows the flight flying in the opposite direction. A minor version of this error can show planes pointing in the wrong direction, but flying in the right direction.
Issues with Our Data
We maintain a database of over 250,000 aircraft and making sure this database is up-to-date is something we work on everyday. But try as we might, the database will never be 100 percent correct. Sometimes aircraft change owners and registrations are scrapped or re-used, so we may end up showing a helicopter flying at 45,000 feet.
We can also end up showing the same flight twice. When we have an ADS-B or MLAT track and FAA data, but don’t make a positive match between the two, we may show two icons for the same flight. The ADS-B or MLAT icon will be correctly positioned, while the FAA-based icon will be 5 minutes flying time in trail.
Every now and then, we’ll display a prop plane traveling at 600 knots or descending at 6000 feet per minute. These errors can occur when we’re tracking a flight with MLAT. For flights being tracked with MLAT the location data is not from the transponder, it is calculated. The speed of an MLAT flight is calculated based on how long it took to fly between two calculated points. MLAT position calculations have a general accuracy of 10-100 meters and 1000 meters in the worst cases. If both calculated positions are incorrect, then the speed we calculate is incorrect, which can lead to a single-engine prop plane nearing the speed of sound.
We track flights based on information received from the aircraft’s transponder, but route information is not broadcast by the transponder, so we supplement transponder information with additional data sources. We use the flight’s call sign to match to the airline’s flight schedules to display the route and scheduled time. For charter, special, delivery, ambulance, cargo flights, and private flights there are no schedules to match against and the route is estimated based on previous flights and call sign usage. But many times, human error can cause us to mistakenly identify flights. If a pilot forgets to change the call sign after a flight or types in the wrong call sign into the flight management computer, we’ll display the flight incorrectly. Flights are often allowed to continue with the wrong call sign because ATC is using the transponder code to identify the flight, not the call sign.
The next time you see a plane land outside the runway, a switchback flightpath, or a flying car rest assured your eyes aren’t playing tricks on you. If you see any errors on our site or in the apps, please point them out to us on Twitter or Facebook as every instance we know about helps us correct the error.