Clearing up Call Sign Confusion
Every few months, when airlines introduce updated schedules, we note that some routes may initially be displayed incorrectly on Flightradar24 because of new call signs. The new call signs that most affect route matching are the alphanumeric call signs used by an increasing number of airlines. We’ll explain how alphanumeric call signs have made our job slightly more difficult, but have made flying even safer.
What’s in a call sign?
Call signs are used by flight crews and air traffic control to identify individual flights on the controller’s screen and over the radio. A call sign may or may not match the flight number and some airlines have radio call signs that differ from the airline’s name. For example, British Airways flight 238 between Boston and London would display the commercial flight number BA238 on passengers’ boarding cards, airport signage, and in flight announcements. To the air traffic controllers it appears as BAW29G and when the controllers and pilots communicate via radio, you would hear ‘Speedbird Two Niner Golf ’ on the radio, as Speedbird is the radio call sign for British Airways. The commercial flight number, which most people commonly associate with a flight, includes the airline’s two digit IATA identifier and the airline-assigned flight number. The full call sign includes the airline’s three digit ICAO identifier and the airline-assigned numeric or alphanumeric digits.
Why not make them the same?
For a long time, a flight’s commercial flight number and call sign were the same apart from the initial IATA/ICAO identifier. As the number of flights worldwide increased and as more flights were in close proximity to each other, airlines and air navigation service providers (ANSP) looked for ways to reduce call sign similarity (CSS) that leads to call sign confusion and possible safety issues. Call sign similarity can occur when two flights are operating in the same airspace on the same radio frequency with call signs that look or sound similar to each other or to a commonly stated phrase on that radio frequency, such as a runway assignment. For example, Air France 1531 and Ryanair 1531 might be climbing out of Paris airspace at the same time and mistake instructions meant for the other flight as their own. Beyond identical call signs, other factors contribute to CSS, such as anagrams (1531 vs 1351); similar end pairs (2124 vs 3124); digit repetition (555, 1117, etc); common information elements like runway names, flight levels, altimeter values, and many more.
To reduce the likelihood of call sign confusion resulting from call sign similarity, airlines and ANSPs turned to alphanumeric call signs. Alphanumeric call signs replace the formerly purely numeric call signs and are assigned to flights to in such a way as to maximize the differences between call signs and minimize the likelihood of confusion in a method called deconfliction. Organizations, such as Eurocontrol have developed tools to assist airlines in deconflicting their call signs across their network. Alphanumeric call signs have been most common in Europe, but they’re now spreading to other regions, most notably the Middle East.
Not all airlines have adopted alphanumeric call signs yet as some barriers to implementation exist at the regional or national level, but an increasing number of airlines are making use of them. Also, not all flights operated by an airline may use an alphanumeric call sign, remember the goal is to reduce similarity with other call signs, so leaving some numeric call signs makes sense.
To arrive at alphanumeric call signs, certain airlines append a character to the flight number, so Virgin Atlantic flight 1 would become VIR1F (Virgin One Foxtrot over the radio). Others remove numeric characters and then add a letter, for example Aer Lingus flight 174 becomes EIN17A (or Shamrock One Seven Alfa over the radio).
Papa and Tango — Often, airlines will append P to the end of a call sign when conducting a positioning or ferry flight and T to end of a call sign when conducting a training flight.
In the British Airways example above, the flight was just assigned a call sign that would be sure not to conflict with other flights. In limited circumstances, airlines will replace the flight number with a separate all-numeric call sign, like KLM in the case of this Amsterdam-San Francisco flight 605, which used the call sign KLM281. Some airlines maintain the same call sign for a particular flight number, while others change on a daily basis.
How does this affect Flightradar24?
The ADS-B message emitted by the aircraft only includes the call sign for the flight, not route or commercial flight number. We acquire flight schedules data from third-party schedule providers and then match call signs to flight numbers using proprietary databases and machine learning. When call signs change during the seasonal schedule updates (or sometimes on a daily basis for some airlines), depending on the airline and geographical area, it may take 1 or 2 flights to rematch the call signs to flight numbers. Alphanumeric call signs have made processing flight data slightly more difficult for us, but the safety gains are more than worth the work.